Going Against the Curve: How to Profit During Economic Recessions

Let's talk about something most people dread: economic recessions. Those doom-and-gloom periods when headlines scream about market crashes, unemployment spikes, and general economic misery. While the average investor runs for the hills during these times (often selling at the worst possible moment), the truly savvy ones are quietly positioning themselves to build generational wealth.

That's right - I'm going to show you how economic downturns can actually be prime opportunities for building wealth, if you know what you're doing. I call this "going against the curve," and it's the investing strategy that has created more millionaires than any bull market ever could.

The Psychology of Recession Investing

Before diving into specific investment approaches, we need to address the elephant in the room: fear. When markets crash, our primitive brains kick into survival mode. We panic. We make emotional decisions. This is precisely why Warren Buffett's famous quote becomes so relevant:

"Be fearful when others are greedy and greedy when others are fearful."

This isn't just clever wordplay - it's the fundamental principle behind contrarian investing. When everyone is selling in panic, prices get artificially depressed, creating buying opportunities that simply don't exist during bull markets.

Economic Indicators: Your Recession Early Warning System

Before you can profit from a recession, you need to know one is coming. Here are the indicators the pros watch:

Leading Economic Index (LEI)

The Conference Board's Leading Economic Index is a composite of ten forward-looking indicators designed to predict economic activity. When the LEI has fallen for several consecutive months, particularly if the six-month rate of decline falls below -4.3%, recession warning bells should be ringing in your head. The LEI typically peaks about 11-12 months before a recession begins, giving you ample time to position your portfolio.

The LEI comprises ten components that collectively signal future economic conditions¹:

1. Average weekly hours in manufacturing
2. Average weekly initial claims for unemployment insurance
3. Manufacturers' new orders for consumer goods and materials
4. ISM® Index of New Orders
5. Manufacturers' new orders for nondefense capital goods excluding aircraft orders
6. Building permits for new private housing units
7. S&P 500® Index of Stock Prices
8. Leading Credit Index™
9. Interest rate spread (10-year Treasury bonds less federal funds rate)
10. Average consumer expectations for business conditions

According to The Conference Board's research, the LEI has correctly predicted every U.S. recession since the 1960s, typically with a lead time of 7-12 months before the economic downturn begins².

Inverted Yield Curve

This is the big one. An inverted yield curve occurs when short-term government bonds yield more than long-term bonds - essentially signaling that investors have more confidence in the short-term economy than the long-term. Historically, when the 10-year Treasury yield falls below the 2-year yield, a recession has followed within 6-24 months with remarkable consistency.

The beauty of the inverted yield curve is its reliability. Since the 1950s, it has predicted virtually every recession with very few false signals - making it the economic equivalent of seeing dark clouds before a storm.

A 2018 research paper by the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco found that the inverted yield curve has preceded all nine U.S. recessions since 1955, with only one false signal in the mid-1960s³. The median time between the initial inversion and the start of a recession was about 12 months.

OECD Composite Leading Indicator (CLI)

The Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) publishes its own composite leading indicator, designed to provide early signals of turning points in business cycles. The CLI is constructed to identify economic fluctuations relative to long-term trends, with readings below 100 suggesting below-trend growth ahead.

The OECD CLI has successfully predicted all major global economic downturns since the 1970s, with an average lead time of 6-9 months⁴. What makes the CLI particularly valuable is its international scope, covering 33 OECD member countries plus 6 major non-member economies like China and India.

Chicago Fed National Activity Index (CFNAI)

The CFNAI is a monthly index designed to gauge overall economic activity and related inflationary pressure. It's a weighted average of 85 existing monthly indicators of national economic activity, making it broader than many other indices.

Research from the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago has shown that when the three-month moving average of the CFNAI falls below -0.7 following a period of economic expansion, there is an increased likelihood that a recession has begun⁵. This indicator is particularly useful because it incorporates data from four broad categories:

• Production and income
• Employment, unemployment, and hours
• Personal consumption and housing
• Sales, orders, and inventories

Purchasing Managers' Index (PMI)

The PMI is a monthly survey of private sector companies that provides information about current and future business conditions. Published by the Institute for Supply Management (ISM), the PMI is one of the most closely watched indicators of manufacturing activity.

A PMI reading below 50 indicates contraction in the manufacturing sector, while readings above 50 signal expansion. Research has shown that when the manufacturing PMI falls below 45 for two consecutive months, a broader economic recession often follows within 3-6 months⁶.

Other Indicators Worth Monitoring

• Initial Jobless Claims: A sudden sustained rise in weekly unemployment claims often precedes economic contractions
• Consumer Sentiment: Measured by the University of Michigan Consumer Sentiment Index, sharp declines often precede reduced consumer spending
• Corporate Profit Margins: Compression in profit margins frequently leads to reduced business investment and hiring
• Credit Spreads: Widening spreads between corporate bonds and Treasury securities signal increasing market stress

The Four Investment Kingdoms: Where to Put Your Money

Now let's talk about the four major asset classes and how they typically perform during recessions.

1. Real Estate: The Concrete Gold Mine

Real estate typically experiences significant price drops during recessions, creating exceptional buying opportunities. Consider these strategies:

Pros during recession:

• Distressed properties become available at substantial discounts
• Lower interest rates (central banks cut rates to stimulate economy) mean cheaper financing
• Reduced competition from other buyers
• Cash flow opportunities from rental properties

Cons during recession:

• Property values may continue declining after purchase
• Tenant defaults and vacancies can increase
• Financing might be harder to obtain despite lower rates
• Property maintenance costs remain regardless of income

Recession strategy: Look for properties in stable neighborhoods with strong rental demand. Focus on cash flow rather than appreciation potential. Be extremely selective and maintain a significant cash buffer for unexpected expenses. Real estate investment trusts (REITs) focusing on necessity-based commercial properties (grocery-anchored shopping centers, medical offices) can be excellent alternatives to direct ownership.

According to research from the National Bureau of Economic Research, residential real estate prices declined by an average of 19.7% during the past three major U.S. recessions, creating significant buying opportunities for well-positioned investors⁷.

I once met a real estate investor who built a portfolio of 15 rental properties during the 2008-2012 housing crash. He followed a simple rule: each property needed to generate at least 12% cash-on-cash return based on recession-level rents. By 2020, his portfolio had tripled in value while providing consistent income throughout the ownership period.

2. Commodities: Hard Assets for Hard Times

Commodities perform uniquely during economic contractions, with significant variation between different types.

Pros during recession:

• Gold often serves as a safe haven during financial turmoil
• Agricultural commodities remain necessary regardless of economic conditions
• Energy commodities eventually rebound as economic activity recovers
• Can provide portfolio diversification when stocks and bonds struggle

Cons during recession:

• Industrial commodities (copper, steel) can crash as manufacturing contracts
• Storage and holding costs for physical commodities
• High volatility and potential liquidity issues
• No income generation capability (unlike stocks or bonds)

Recession strategy: Focus on gold and consumer staple agricultural commodities. Consider using ETFs rather than futures contracts to avoid complexity and leverage risks. Gradually accumulate industrial commodities as the recession deepens, positioning for the eventual recovery.

Research from the World Gold Council shows that gold has delivered positive returns during 7 of the 8 recessions since 1970, with an average performance of +10.8% when equity markets declined⁸.

During the 2020 COVID crash, gold initially fell alongside stocks but quickly rebounded and gained over 30% that year. Meanwhile, oil prices briefly went negative (an unprecedented event), demonstrating how different commodities can behave during crisis periods.

3. Stocks: Buying Businesses on Sale

Stock markets typically experience significant declines during recessions, with the S&P 500 falling 20-40% in modern recessions. However, this creates exceptional opportunities.

Pros during recession:

• Quality companies trade at deep discounts to intrinsic value
• Dividend yields increase as prices fall
• Once-in-a-decade opportunities in certain sectors
• Ability to accumulate positions in growing industries

Cons during recession:

• Painful paper losses if buying too early
• Dividend cuts from struggling companies
• Potential bankruptcy of overleveraged businesses
• Psychological difficulty buying when headlines are most negative

Recession strategy: Focus on companies with strong balance sheets (low debt), stable cash flows, and essential products/services. Consumer staples (Procter & Gamble, Coca-Cola), healthcare (Johnson & Johnson), utilities, and discount retailers (Walmart) typically outperform during recessions.

A study by J.P. Morgan Asset Management found that five of the S&P 500's best 10 trading days in each decade occurred within two weeks of the 10 worst days⁹. This highlights why staying invested (or even better, adding to positions) during market panics is crucial for long-term returns.

If you're more aggressive, consider carefully selected companies in cyclical industries after significant price declines. In March 2020, for example, many quality bank stocks traded at 50% of book value, subsequently doubling or tripling when economic fears subsided.

4. Fixed Income: Bonds and Beyond

The fourth investment kingdom - bonds and fixed income - plays a crucial role during economic contractions.

Pros during recession:

• Government bonds typically appreciate as interest rates fall
• Provide income during uncertain times
• High-quality corporate bonds eventually offer attractive yields
• Serve as portfolio stabilizers

Cons during recession:

• High-yield (junk) bonds can crash alongside stocks
• Default risk increases for corporate issuers
• Inflation risk if central banks implement aggressive monetary stimulus
• Opportunity cost if bought too early in the cycle

Recession strategy: Maintain a ladder of high-quality government and investment-grade corporate bonds. As the recession deepens, gradually increase allocation to higher-yielding corporate bonds from financially solid companies. Consider Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities (TIPS) to hedge against potential inflation from stimulus measures.

Research from PIMCO has shown that U.S. Treasury bonds delivered positive returns in all eight recession periods since 1973, with an average return of 8.1% during these economic contractions¹⁰.

During the 2008 financial crisis, U.S. Treasury bonds gained over 20% while stocks crashed 50%. Later in the crisis, certain investment-grade corporate bonds offered yields exceeding 8% with minimal default risk - essentially allowing fixed-income investors to "lock in" equity-like returns with significantly less risk.

Shorting the Crisis: Advanced Strategies

For investors with higher risk tolerance and experience, economic crises present unique shorting opportunities. Here are some approaches to consider, though proceed with extreme caution:

Identifying Vulnerable Sectors

During the early stages of recession, focus on:

• Luxury goods manufacturers and retailers
• Companies with high debt loads and poor cash flow
• Cyclical industries heavily dependent on discretionary spending
• Financial institutions with exposure to deteriorating asset classes

For example, in 2007-2008, homebuilders, mortgage lenders, and financial companies with subprime exposure experienced catastrophic declines. In 2020, cruise lines, airlines, and hotel chains saw similar collapses.

Shorting Methods

There are several ways to implement short positions:

• Inverse ETFs: These funds are designed to move opposite to their target index or sector
• Put options: Provide leveraged exposure to downside moves with defined risk
• Short selling individual stocks: Only for experienced investors due to unlimited theoretical risk
• Credit default swaps: Complex derivatives that increase in value as credit quality deteriorates

A study by the Financial Analysts Journal found that adding a modest allocation (5-10%) to managed short positions during recessions improved risk-adjusted portfolio returns over full market cycles¹¹.

The most famous example of crisis shorting was Michael Burry (portrayed in "The Big Short"), who made billions betting against subprime mortgage bonds. As he explained in his post-crisis interviews:

"I started getting bearish on the subprime market in 2003, when I saw the first no-money-down mortgages being marketed... It took years before the market realized what was happening."

A Word of Caution

Shorting requires excellent timing, strong risk management, and emotional discipline. Even the most obvious short candidates can experience dramatic short-term rallies that can wipe out poorly timed positions. Use small position sizes and strict risk controls if pursuing this strategy.

Specific Examples: Crisis Investing Opportunities

Let me share some specific examples of contrarian investments that delivered exceptional returns during past recessions:

2008-2009 Financial Crisis

• American Express (AXP): Fell from $60 to $10 on fears of credit card defaults. Warren Buffett doubled his position. By 2013, it had recovered to $80.
• Las Vegas Sands (LVS): Crashed from $140 to $1.50 on bankruptcy fears. Rebounded to $50+ within three years.
• Apple (AAPL): Dropped to $12 (split-adjusted) during market panic. Would be worth over $3,000 today with dividends reinvested.

2020 COVID Crisis

• Carnival Cruise (CCL): Plunged from $50 to $8. Rebounded to $30 within a year.
• Bank of America (BAC): Fell from $35 to $18. Recovered to $40+ as economic fears subsided.
• Disney (DIS): Dropped from $150 to $85 as parks closed. Reached new all-time highs within 12 months.

The key pattern? Quality companies in temporarily distressed industries offer the greatest upside potential during crisis periods.

Building Your Recession Playbook

Here's how to create your personal recession investment strategy:

1. Preparation Phase (When yield curve inverts):

   • Build cash reserves (aim for 20-30% of portfolio)
   • Create a shopping list of quality assets to buy during the downturn
   • Reduce exposure to highly cyclical industries
   • Consider adding small hedge positions

2. Early Recession Phase (Economic data deteriorating):

   • Begin deploying cash gradually into highest-quality assets
   • Focus on dividend aristocrats and consumer staples
   • Increase bond allocation, especially government bonds
   • Maintain discipline while others panic

3. Deep Recession Phase (Maximum pessimism):

   • Deploy capital more aggressively
   • Look for opportunities in distressed sectors
   • Begin positioning for eventual recovery
   • Remember Buffett's wisdom about being greedy when others are fearful

4. Recovery Positioning (Economic indicators bottoming):

   • Shift toward more cyclical industries
   • Reduce bond allocation in favor of equities
   • Consider small positions in the most beaten-down sectors
   • Be patient - recoveries often take longer than expected

As Howard Marks writes in his book "Mastering the Market Cycle":

"The most dangerous words in investing are 'this time it's different.' Every crisis feels unique when you're in it. But the pattern of excessive optimism followed by excessive pessimism has repeated throughout market history."

Final Thoughts

Economic recessions are inevitable parts of the business cycle. Rather than fearing them, sophisticated investors understand they create the richest opportunities for those with preparation, capital, and emotional discipline.

Remember that the greatest fortunes aren't made by following the crowd. They're made by having the courage to go against it - by buying quality assets when everyone else is selling them, and by maintaining a long-term perspective when others are trapped in short-term panic.

So the next time you see headlines about economic doom, remember this blog post. That may just be your signal to begin deploying capital while whispering to yourself: "It's time to go against the curve."

New Venture Finance: Startup Funding for Entrepreneurs